How Thermodynamics Explains the Origins of Living Things
July 13, 2020
England, a physicist and rabbi, debuts with an ambitious but disappointing multidisciplinary inquiry into the origin and meaning of life. Interested in the question of how life is differentiated from nonlife, he asks what physics can reveal about “when and how things that are not alive start to become more lifelike.” England also moves into the philosophical and theological realms, addressing such questions as “Are humans simply animals, or something more?” with guidance from the Hebrew Bible. However, the bulk of the book deals with physics, including entropy, the nature of time, and energy flow, as well as his own hypothesis “that building blocks with diverse possible response properties to a given drive should spontaneously organize themselves to either reduce their energy absorption or else direct it into powering orderly, regular motion.” Amid all this, biology is often lost. Similarly, though each chapter begins with a quotation from Exodus or Genesis, these are only fleetingly integrated into the text. Those attracted by England’s lofty premise are unlikely to be satisfied by the diffuse execution.
July 1, 2020
A largely successful effort to explain biology through the principles of physics. Physics depends heavily on reductionism: breaking complex actions down to the simplest mechanism. This holds little appeal to biologists who deal with the messy phenomenon of life. England, a former associate professor of physics at MIT who is now senior director in artificial intelligence at GlaxoSmithKline, begins with a problem: Every living thing has sprung from another living thing, but that "implies that the first life that ever was grew from stuff that was not alive," so the laws of chemistry and physics had to be involved. Life is clearly an emergent property, which England illustrates by the example of a frog put through a blender. Every atom remains, but it is no longer a frog. The author introduces two physical concepts that explain how a complex frog emerges from a few trillion elemental atoms. The first is "macroscopic coarse-graining," which maintains that any system can be described by numbers specifying what every individual particle is doing. This works for simple systems such as crystals; while impossible for even the most primitive organism, it enables scientists to create useful models. The second concept, entropy, measures the probability that a collection of atoms will assemble into something interesting such as a frog. Overwhelmingly, it won't, but the odds are not zero, and they can be calculated. Seen as a measure of disorder, entropy is extremely low in a living organism. Living things keep their entropy low by extracting energy from the environment through eating and respiration. Since total energy in the universe remains constant, this is a complex process that England explains using many simple drawings of curves that go up and down because that's how energy flows. The process is simple, but the details are not. Those who put in the effort to read closely will discover illuminating insights into the physics of life.
COPYRIGHT(2020) Kirkus Reviews, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.